• Subscribe Now
  • Today In History
  • Wars & Events
    • The Russia–Ukraine War
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • Cold War
    • Korean War
    • Vietnam War
    • Global War on Terror
    • Movements
      • Women’s Rights
      • Civil Rights
      • Abolition of Slavery
  • Famous People
    • U.S. Presidents
    • World Leaders
    • Military Leaders
    • Outlaws & Lawmen
    • Activists
    • Artists & Writers
    • Celebrities
    • Scientists
    • Philosophers
  • Eras
    • Modern Era
      • 2000s
      • 1900s
      • 1800s
    • Early Modern
      • 1700s
      • 1600s
      • 1500s
    • The Middle Ages
    • Classical Era
    • Prehistory
  • Topics
    • Black History
    • Slavery
    • Women’s History
    • Prisoners of War
    • Firsthand Accounts
    • Technology & Weaponry
    • Aviation & Spaceflight
    • Naval & Maritime
    • Politics
    • Military History
    • Art & Literature
    • News
    • Entertainment & Culture
    • Historical Figures
    • Photography
    • Wild West
    • Social History
    • Native American History
  • Magazines
    • American History
    • America’s Civil War
    • Aviation History
    • Civil War Times
    • Military History
    • Military History Quarterly
    • Vietnam
    • Wild West
    • World War II
  • Newsletters
  • Podcasts
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
Skip to content
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
HistoryNet

HistoryNet

The most comprehensive and authoritative history site on the Internet.

  • Subscribe Now
  • Today In History
  • Wars & Events
    • The Russia–Ukraine War
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • Cold War
    • Korean War
    • Vietnam War
    • Global War on Terror
    • Movements
      • Women’s Rights
      • Civil Rights
      • Abolition of Slavery
  • Famous People
    • U.S. Presidents
    • World Leaders
    • Military Leaders
    • Outlaws & Lawmen
    • Activists
    • Artists & Writers
    • Celebrities
    • Scientists
    • Philosophers
  • Eras
    • Modern Era
      • 2000s
      • 1900s
      • 1800s
    • Early Modern
      • 1700s
      • 1600s
      • 1500s
    • The Middle Ages
    • Classical Era
    • Prehistory
  • Topics
    • Black History
    • Slavery
    • Women’s History
    • Prisoners of War
    • Firsthand Accounts
    • Technology & Weaponry
    • Aviation & Spaceflight
    • Naval & Maritime
    • Politics
    • Military History
    • Art & Literature
    • News
    • Entertainment & Culture
    • Historical Figures
    • Photography
    • Wild West
    • Social History
    • Native American History
  • Magazines
    • American History
    • America’s Civil War
    • Aviation History
    • Civil War Times
    • Military History
    • Military History Quarterly
    • Vietnam
    • Wild West
    • World War II
  • Newsletters
  • Podcasts
Posted inReview

People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review)

by HistoryNet Staff6/12/20068/2/2016
Share This Article

Reviewed by James Andrew Nichols
By David Williams
The New Press

The American Civil War is often viewed through the lens of “great men and great events”: the battlefield victories and defeats of Federal and Confederate generals; the declarations of socio-economic independence; the struggle to free an enslaved population. However, historians often overlook the voices of the non-planter class — the frontline soldier, the factory worker, the dissenter, women — as they try to re-create the war and its many facets. David Williams attempts to give life and agency to these “smaller voices” that have been lost within a popular narrative typically aimed at supporting the lore of either the Lost Cause or the Great Emancipator. The framework of the text is built around the notion that the Confederacy was bound to fail in its objective of establishing an independent slaveocracy, because it was hindered by socio-economic infighting, a resistant slave populace and the Federal government’s attempts to maintain the Union. The author uses a cross-section of American voices drawn from newspapers, letters and diaries to show how the “plain folk” exerted their agency in shaping the war within that framework. By bringing together their stories in a layered manner, the author gives readers another, more powerful way to view the Civil War — as groups of people who shaped the course of the war not by moving forward at the bequest of its leaders, but by operating as integral parts in the socio-political processes at the local, state and national levels.

Following in the footsteps of historian Howard Zinn, who pioneered “people’s history” Williams’ method of viewing the Civil War through the eyes of marginalized people goes a great distance in trying to tear down the notion of an emotionally and materially committed independent Confederacy, as well as the idea that a strong and popularly supported war effort to save the Union existed in the North.

For instance, a chapter on the role of women in the downfall of the Confederacy focuses on how lower class white women in the South exerted influence through political advocacy or direct physical intervention. One such example occurred early in the spring of 1863, when women rioted across the South, breaking into government storehouses and flaunting local enforcement in an effort to feed and clothe their families who were suffering at the hands of the planter class and government corruption. There was nothing localized about this incident. As a matter of fact, as the war dragged on, an increasing number of female-dominated households turned to larceny and burglary in an attempt to feed their families. A Confederate commissary official wrote in March 1865 that desperate poor women were breaking into his commissary and liberating his foodstuffs; unable to police the commissary, he simply stood by in the face of their desperation.

With the planter class using prime farmland for tobacco and cotton, the food supply dwindled, forcing wives and mothers to beg their husbands and sons to desert and tend to their starving families. The rash acts that women resorted to in order to secure subsistence provided a catalyst for men in the Confederate armies to abandon the cause and return home in ever-increasing numbers. Confederate muster roles and official correspondence support the impact that women had on the armies’ ability to operate effectively on the battlefield.

One of the drawbacks to Williams’ text is his use of language with regard to defining and generalizing groups of people. He uses the term “plain folk” or “common people” throughout his text to describe those not belonging to the planter class and possessing no slaves, and liberally applies this title to all other people who do not qualify as the landed elite. This becomes a point of contention because the distinction between individuals and communities is tremendous not only within each state but across the Confederacy. Each local community was a confluence of complex socio-economic forces that both shaped and were shaped by its citizenry. To lump all farmers, women, soldiers and the less politically influential into a monolithic category and argue that they felt slighted, empowered or apathetic is disingenuous when attempting to flesh out the “small voices.” The first footnote of the text tries to address this trouble spot; unfortunately, it only goes as far as to say that he recognizes the problem in grouping people, and cannot narrow the “common people” down into a manageable study. The author should have more clearly defined his terms, devoted more time to peeling back the layers within the various factions, and not fallen into the trap of painting whole communities with a singular brush.

Overall, Williams’ narrative is a well-written and well-documented journey through the marginalized groups that influenced the course of the Civil War. Broken down along the lines of race, class and gender, the various groups give the reader a much richer understanding of the makeup of a war’s life cycle. This book is a strong counterpoint to the traditional great-men and great-events narratives that are the foundation for so much of the work on this period. This particular investigation into the voices and actions of “plain folks” gives the reader a perspective that is seldom discussed and sorely lacking in most serious examinations of the American Civil War.

Share This Article
by HistoryNet Staff

more by HistoryNet Staff

Dive deeper

  • The Confederacy

Citation information

HistoryNet Staff (6/16/2025) People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review). HistoryNet Retrieved from https://www.historynet.com/peoples-history-of-the-civil-war-struggles-for-the-meaning-of-freedom-book-review/.
"People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review)."HistoryNet Staff - 6/16/2025, https://www.historynet.com/peoples-history-of-the-civil-war-struggles-for-the-meaning-of-freedom-book-review/
HistoryNet Staff 6/12/2006 People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review)., viewed 6/16/2025,<https://www.historynet.com/peoples-history-of-the-civil-war-struggles-for-the-meaning-of-freedom-book-review/>
HistoryNet Staff - People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review). [Internet]. [Accessed 6/16/2025]. Available from: https://www.historynet.com/peoples-history-of-the-civil-war-struggles-for-the-meaning-of-freedom-book-review/
HistoryNet Staff. "People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review)." HistoryNet Staff - Accessed 6/16/2025. https://www.historynet.com/peoples-history-of-the-civil-war-struggles-for-the-meaning-of-freedom-book-review/
"People’s History of the Civil War: Struggles for the Meaning of Freedom (Book Review)." HistoryNet Staff [Online]. Available: https://www.historynet.com/peoples-history-of-the-civil-war-struggles-for-the-meaning-of-freedom-book-review/. [Accessed: 6/16/2025]

Related stories

Stories

Portfolio: Images of War as Landscape

Whether they produced battlefield images of the dead or daguerreotype portraits of common soldiers, […]

Stories

Jerrie Mock: Record-Breaking American Female Pilot

In 1964 an Ohio woman took up the challenge that had led to Amelia Earhart’s disappearance.

Buffalo Bill Cody
Stories

10 Pivotal Events in the Life of Buffalo Bill

William Frederick Cody (1846-1917) led a signal life, from his youthful exploits with the Pony Express and in service as a U.S. Army scout to his globetrotting days as a showman and international icon Buffalo Bill.

ww2-homefront-poster-war-bond
Portfolio

During the War Years, Posters From the American Homefront Told You What to Do — And What Not to Do

If you needed some motivation during the war years, there was probably a poster for that.

HistoryNet
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube

“History is a guide to navigation in perilous times. History is who we are and why we are the way we are.”

David McCullough, author of “1776”

HistoryNet.com is brought to you by HistoryNet LLC, the world’s largest publisher of history magazines. HistoryNet.com contains daily features, photo galleries and over 25,000 articles originally published in our nine magazines.

Our Magazines

  • American History
  • America’s Civil War
  • Aviation History
  • Civil War Times
  • Military History
  • Military History Quarterly
  • Vietnam
  • Wild West
  • World War II

About Us

  • What Is HistoryNet.com?
  • Advertise With Us
  • Careers
  • Meet Our Staff!

Stay Curious

Subscribe to receive our weekly newsletter with top stories from master historians.

sign me up!

© 2025 HistoryNet.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service