• Subscribe Now
  • Today In History
  • Wars & Events
    • The Russia–Ukraine War
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • Cold War
    • Korean War
    • Vietnam War
    • Global War on Terror
    • Movements
      • Women’s Rights
      • Civil Rights
      • Abolition of Slavery
  • Famous People
    • U.S. Presidents
    • World Leaders
    • Military Leaders
    • Outlaws & Lawmen
    • Activists
    • Artists & Writers
    • Celebrities
    • Scientists
    • Philosophers
  • Eras
    • Modern Era
      • 2000s
      • 1900s
      • 1800s
    • Early Modern
      • 1700s
      • 1600s
      • 1500s
    • The Middle Ages
    • Classical Era
    • Prehistory
  • Topics
    • Black History
    • Slavery
    • Women’s History
    • Prisoners of War
    • Firsthand Accounts
    • Technology & Weaponry
    • Aviation & Spaceflight
    • Naval & Maritime
    • Politics
    • Military History
    • Art & Literature
    • News
    • Entertainment & Culture
    • Historical Figures
    • Photography
    • Wild West
    • Social History
    • Native American History
  • Magazines
    • American History
    • America’s Civil War
    • Aviation History
    • Civil War Times
    • Military History
    • Military History Quarterly
    • Vietnam
    • Wild West
    • World War II
  • Newsletters
  • Podcasts
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
Skip to content
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
HistoryNet

HistoryNet

The most comprehensive and authoritative history site on the Internet.

  • Subscribe Now
  • Today In History
  • Wars & Events
    • The Russia–Ukraine War
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • Cold War
    • Korean War
    • Vietnam War
    • Global War on Terror
    • Movements
      • Women’s Rights
      • Civil Rights
      • Abolition of Slavery
  • Famous People
    • U.S. Presidents
    • World Leaders
    • Military Leaders
    • Outlaws & Lawmen
    • Activists
    • Artists & Writers
    • Celebrities
    • Scientists
    • Philosophers
  • Eras
    • Modern Era
      • 2000s
      • 1900s
      • 1800s
    • Early Modern
      • 1700s
      • 1600s
      • 1500s
    • The Middle Ages
    • Classical Era
    • Prehistory
  • Topics
    • Black History
    • Slavery
    • Women’s History
    • Prisoners of War
    • Firsthand Accounts
    • Technology & Weaponry
    • Aviation & Spaceflight
    • Naval & Maritime
    • Politics
    • Military History
    • Art & Literature
    • News
    • Entertainment & Culture
    • Historical Figures
    • Photography
    • Wild West
    • Social History
    • Native American History
  • Magazines
    • American History
    • America’s Civil War
    • Aviation History
    • Civil War Times
    • Military History
    • Military History Quarterly
    • Vietnam
    • Wild West
    • World War II
  • Newsletters
  • Podcasts
Posted inReview

Book Review: Remembering the Civil War

by Gordon Berg2/24/20175/17/2017
Share This Article

Remembering the Civil War: Reunion and the Limits of Reconciliation

 Caroline E. Janney, University of North Carolina Press

On the 50th anniversary of the Battle of Gettysburg in 1913, former Confederate soldier and then-Virginia Governor William H. Mann declared, “There is no North, no South, no rebels, no Yanks.” Mann was repeating a shibboleth, familiar to many hearers, that “all is one great nation.” Caroline Janney’s account of how the war has been remembered and memorialized shows just how wrong Mann was. Her revisionist study  argues that the Lost Cause mythology and rush to reconciliation was much less pervasive than previously thought.

Janney points out that historical memories associated with terms such as “emancipationist,” “reunionist” and “reconciliationist” should be understood through a widely focused sociological lens that changed over time and were understood differently by different groups of people. “Perhaps most important,” Janney contends, “these stories remind us that the memory of the war had profound implications for partisan politics, government policy, citizenship, ideas about gender and race, and the  future of the nation.” Even as the nation commemorates the sesquicentennial, Janney reminds us, “divisiveness and competing memories have not disappeared.”

Janney’s earlier study of Ladies Memorial Associations throughout the South strengthens her argument that women played a prominent role in shaping memorialization of the war. “In the fifty years since the  war,” she maintains, “veterans seemed to have found reasons to shake hands with their former foes in the name of reconciliation, but the women—of both sides—would not be so quick to join forces.” By making Lost Cause mythology synonymous with family, home, moral righteousness and female virtue, organizations such as the United Daughters of  the Confederacy ever so slowly began to overshadow the Union Cause.

Though ending slavery was an integral component of the Union cause, Northerners did not necessarily support civil and political rights for newly freed African Americans. Janney explains how Union veterans “could embrace both reconciliation and emancipation” because, for the Union cause to triumph, “the victorious North had to welcome white southerners back into the national fold.” Union veterans, Janney asserts, “never forgot that they had fought against treason” and, while they might shake hands across a stone wall, “they never sold out to Confederate memories.”

Janney also describes how African Americans have “waged their own battles to control the war’s memory.” For them, race and slavery could never be separated. African Americans extolled the vital role “colored troops” played in preserving the Union, attended Memorial Day ceremonies, advocated a national Emancipation Day and collected money for memorials. Perhaps the wreath sent by President Barack Obama in 2011 to the African American Civil War Memorial in Washington, D.C., which lists the name of every black soldier and sailor, represents the nation’s 21st-century commitment to grappling with the war’s complexities in order to better understand its legacy for all Americans.

 

Originally published in the February 2014 issue of Civil War Times. To subscribe, click here.

Share This Article
by Gordon Berg

more by Gordon Berg

    Citation information

    Gordon Berg (6/17/2025) Book Review: Remembering the Civil War. HistoryNet Retrieved from https://www.historynet.com/book-review-remembering-civil-war/.
    "Book Review: Remembering the Civil War."Gordon Berg - 6/17/2025, https://www.historynet.com/book-review-remembering-civil-war/
    Gordon Berg 2/24/2017 Book Review: Remembering the Civil War., viewed 6/17/2025,<https://www.historynet.com/book-review-remembering-civil-war/>
    Gordon Berg - Book Review: Remembering the Civil War. [Internet]. [Accessed 6/17/2025]. Available from: https://www.historynet.com/book-review-remembering-civil-war/
    Gordon Berg. "Book Review: Remembering the Civil War." Gordon Berg - Accessed 6/17/2025. https://www.historynet.com/book-review-remembering-civil-war/
    "Book Review: Remembering the Civil War." Gordon Berg [Online]. Available: https://www.historynet.com/book-review-remembering-civil-war/. [Accessed: 6/17/2025]

    Related stories

    Stories

    Portfolio: Images of War as Landscape

    Whether they produced battlefield images of the dead or daguerreotype portraits of common soldiers, […]

    Stories

    Jerrie Mock: Record-Breaking American Female Pilot

    In 1964 an Ohio woman took up the challenge that had led to Amelia Earhart’s disappearance.

    ww2-homefront-poster-war-bond
    Portfolio

    During the War Years, Posters From the American Homefront Told You What to Do — And What Not to Do

    If you needed some motivation during the war years, there was probably a poster for that.

    Mary Thompson house
    Travel

    Gettysburg Had a Lasting Impact on Its Least Known Participants — Its Civilians

    Travel along the famous sites of Gettysburg, from the Cashtown Inn to Lee’s headquarters, from the eyes of the locals.

    HistoryNet
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram
    • YouTube

    “History is a guide to navigation in perilous times. History is who we are and why we are the way we are.”

    David McCullough, author of “1776”

    HistoryNet.com is brought to you by HistoryNet LLC, the world’s largest publisher of history magazines. HistoryNet.com contains daily features, photo galleries and over 25,000 articles originally published in our nine magazines.

    Our Magazines

    • American History
    • America’s Civil War
    • Aviation History
    • Civil War Times
    • Military History
    • Military History Quarterly
    • Vietnam
    • Wild West
    • World War II

    About Us

    • What Is HistoryNet.com?
    • Advertise With Us
    • Careers
    • Meet Our Staff!

    Stay Curious

    Subscribe to receive our weekly newsletter with top stories from master historians.

    sign me up!

    © 2025 HistoryNet.
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service