Studies and Observations Group | HistoryNet MENU

Studies and Observations Group

By Rob Krott
8/12/2001 • Reviews, Vietnam Book Reviews

MACV-SOG–Military Assistance Command, Vietnam–Special Operations Group (later renamed Studies and Observations Group)–was the elite military unit of the Vietnam War, so secret that its existence was denied by the U.S. government. The group reported directly to the Pentagon’s Joint Chiefs of Staff, and much of its history and exploits were concealed for years from the general public by a veil of secrecy and confidentiality. John L. Plaster served three one-year tours with MACV-SOG, and his book SOG: The Secret Wars of America’s Commandos in Vietnam (Simon & Schuster, New York, 1997, $26) is a true insider’s account, revealing much about this top-secret commando unit and its covert missions in North Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia.

The all-volunteer MACV-SOG (most were U.S. Army Special Forces “Green Berets”) carried out some of the most dangerous and challenging special operations of the Vietnam War. MACV-SOG made high-altitude, low-opening parachute jumps behind enemy lines, routinely carried out reconnaissance missions along the Ho Chi Minh Trail, penetrated deep into Laos and Cambodia, recovered downed pilots and attempted several POW rescues. Ranging deep in the enemy’s rear, MACV-SOG reconnaissance teams forced Hanoi to divert 40,000 troops–about four divisions–to rear security missions along the Ho Chi Minh Trail.

From his own personal knowledge of MACV-SOG operations and from interviews with more than 100 MACV-SOG veterans, along with recently declassified documents, Plaster has crafted a heavily anecdotal and riveting account. He offers tales of close, violent combat actions between MACV-SOG teams and large numbers of North Vietnamese Army (NVA) troops. While some infantrymen in Vietnam despaired of ever seeing the enemy, MACV-SOG teams often found themselves fighting their way out of a hornet’s nest of angry NVA battalions. Plaster recounts some of the most extraordinary tales of the Vietnam War. Some stories will lay to rest old rumors; others will just raise more questions. For example, Plaster describes how two Chinese advisers were killed when reconnaissance team (RT) Maine ambushed an NVA company command element, killing the commander, his three platoon leaders and two Chinese advisers as they gathered for lunch. Plaster also tells about the “crazy Canadians” who served in the U.S. Army with MACV-SOG, including Robert Graham, who once carried a Simpsons (Sears) 55-pound hunting bow and shot broadhead-tipped arrows at the NVA during a firefight.

Plaster relates some of MACV-SOG’s lighter moments as well. Mixed in with the pathos of combat is some great humor. Readers will not be disappointed; the book is worth its cover price just for one very funny story about a bicycle. In another amusing anecdote, Harvey “Hippie” Saal walks buck-naked into an NCO club after he is refused entrance for wearing a dirty uniform. There are a number of stories about the legendary Walt Shumate, and Plaster explains why there were so many Walt Shumate stories.

Indeed, MACV-SOG is the stuff of legends. Legends such as the 14 men of RT Kansas who held off an NVA regiment; the captured NVA “Earth Angels” used against their former comrades; the combat high-altitude, low-opening jumps into NVA redoubts; and the men of RT Colorado’s who faced nearly 300 NVA formed in ranks in front of the team’s eight Claymore mines. Another MACV-SOG legend and one of its well-known characters, Jerry “Mad Dog” Shriver, received his sobriquet courtesy of Radio Hanoi. Resplendent when off duty in his derby hat and blue-velvet smoking jacket, his closest companion was Klaus, a German shepherd. Shriver, who often ended up in situations where he was in danger of being overrun, once told his air cover: “No, no. I’ve got ’em right where I want ’em–surrounded from the inside.” Like many MACV-SOG recon men, Shriver’s luck ran out eventually. Last seen assaulting an NVA bunker line, he was declared missing in action.

MACV-SOG had more than its share of MIAs. One of the most well-known was Larry Thorne, a Finnish veteran of the so-called Winter War against the Soviet Union during the prelude to World War II and a recipient of the Mannerheim Cross. Thorne was carrying a bolt-action .30-06 Springfield when he became MACV-SOG’s first MIA in Laos. Stories abound of teams that disappeared without a trace, though sometimes circumstances and evidence (such as proof that NVA concussion grenades had been used) led MACV-SOG to believe that the men were captured. A dozen entire teams are still unaccounted for.

Of the men known to be prisoners of war, only a few returned home alive. No MACV-SOG POWs were released from Laos. Of the 58 MACV-SOG MIAs in Laos, only one returned–Charles Wilklow. Wilklow escaped captivity after being staked out by the NVA as human bait for rescuers for several days. His captors had thought he was too close to death to need a guard, but he managed to crawl off into the jungle and evade recapture until rescued.

MACV-SOG recon casualties exceeded 100 percent, the highest sustained American loss rate since the Civil War. In 1968, every MACV-SOG recon man was wounded at least once, and about half were killed. But despite such high losses, MACV-SOG boasted the highest “kill ratio” in U.S. military history, topping out at 158-to-1 in 1970.

SOG reads like “who’s who” of Green Berets. There are several names that many Vietnam veterans and most Special Forces veterans will recognize: Billy Waugh, Larry Thorne, Dick Meadows, Jerry “Mad Dog” Shriver, Fred Zabitosky, Walter Shumate, Jon Cavaiani, Roy Benavidez, Norm Doney and Robert Howard. Some like Benavidez, Cavaiani, Howard and Zabitosky, are remembered for the deeds that earned them the Medal of Honor. The Medal of Honor was awarded to nine MACV-SOG men, including Lieutenant Tom Morris, a sea-air-land forces (SEAL) officer, and Lieutenant Loren Hagen, the last U.S. Army member to be awarded the Medal of Honor in Vietnam.

With small reconnaissance teams numbering less than 10 men, MACV-SOG tied down thousands of NVA troops, provided invaluable intelligence information to the Pentagon, rescued downed pilots and destroyed large amounts of enemy materiel while inflicting grievous losses on the NVA. Earning their place in history with daring exploits and exemplary accomplishments, the men of MACV’s Special Operations Group have been brought out of the shadows by John L. Plaster’s illuminating book.

11 Responses to Studies and Observations Group

  1. Cynthia Lindsay (Batz) says:

    Hi,
    I am looking to communicate with anyone that might know my Father. His name is Robert (Bob) Batz.

    He has passed away this year, and I an trying to find out more about his time during Vietnam.

    Thank you,
    Cyndie

  2. […] a conditions to his atmosphere support and was told that it sounded “pretty bad.” Shriver’s response became mythological among a special […]

  3. […] the situation to his air support and was told that it sounded “pretty bad.” Shriver’s response became legendary among the special […]

  4. […] the situation to his air support and was told that it sounded “pretty bad.” Shriver’s response became legendary among the special […]

  5. […] the situation to his air support and was told that it sounded “pretty bad.” Shriver’s response became legendary among the special […]

  6. […] the situation to his air support and was told that it sounded “pretty bad.” Shriver’s response became legendary among the special […]

  7. William Stevens says:

    I served with SOG before it became Studies and Observations Group and we trained and jumped Chinese Nungs into NVA on a regular basis in 1963, 64 and 65. We had lots of goodies available to us as we did not report to MACV in the beginning. a small arms collection that would impress any gun shop. How about a Thompson Sub-machine gun with a rotary drum on top. Days of John Dillinger. Swedish K machine pistols with silencers, Zippo lighters with 22 caliber loads in them. It was like the movies of 007 but for real. We lived hard, lost a lot of close buddies, but got really good pay and all the while, no one knew we were there. Until MACV too command.

    • Nic E Appetizer says:

      Do you happen to remember Gerald Wareing..? Jerry Wareing..He would have been there since like 59 with the 7th the 1st and 5th sfg . He is my grandfather and one helluva an instructor to me.

    • Mike Wisniewski says:

      Hi. My name is Mike Wisniewski and I live in Delaware. My father’s name is Robert D. Wisniewski “Bob” or “Ski” and was in the Air Force for 24+ years. He retired in 1989 at Dover AFB and he was an AGE Mechanic for the most part but did serve in Vietnam. He was stationed in the Philippines twice 1968 and 1971 (appxly). Unfortunately, my dad passed away in Oct. 6, 2011. (64yoa)
      After his passing, I met a gentleman name William Frantz who knew my father from Dover AFB. He then asked me did your father ever tell you about the Green Hornets.. I said No, he’s never said anything about that. I then said what was it and Bill was reluctant to tell me because it was classified and at the time did really exist. I recently saw Mr. Frantz yesturday at a funeral and we spoke again and i had a picture of my father’s award which had a Special Forces pin, another that had a skull with a green Green Beret hat and a medal. Mr. Frantz saw the skull pin and said it was a off the record unit then he said MACV-SOG. I would like to know if the is a site that I could chat with to find out more information about this or anyone who knew my Father. Of course it was volunteer only and not on his DD14. Thank you and God Bless all our Veterans.

      • William Stevens says:

        Hello Mike. My sincere condolences for the loss of your father. He passed on a young man. All activity we supported back during the early years of service in Vietnam has now been cleared and available to the public, that is it is no longer classified. The Green Hornets you mention was a Helicopter Squadron that you can find out more about here:

        http://usafhpa.org/20helisq/20hornetsnew/ghstory.htm

        The medallion or pin you mention with a skull and Green Beret was the motto for Special Operations Group which later became Studies and Observations Group that was controlled by MACV. Originally, it was controlled by the CIA via the local US Embassy before the 5th Special Forces Group arrived in Vietnam. All of this has been declassified and you may be able to find some information via the above link that deals more with the Air Force than it does with Special Forces. And there is a lot of info about the Green Hornets. I wish you good luck.

      • Mike Wisniewski says:

        Thank you sir.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

, , , ,



Sponsored Content: