President William McKinley: Assassinated by an Anarchist

President William McKinley: Assassinated by an Anarchist

By Wyatt Kingseed
10/1/2001 • American History Magazine, Politics

Leon Czolgosz stood in line and counted the people between him and the president of the United States. Nondescript, dressed in a dark suit, and wearing an innocent expression, Czolgosz (pronounced chlgsh) looked younger than his 28 years. He had waited for more than two hours in 82-degree heat on September 6, 1901, for his turn to shake hands with President William McKinley, who was visiting the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo, New York.

It was the first year of the new century, a perfect time to reflect on the nation’s rise in world prominence and to speculate on the future. The exposition, a world’s fair that celebrated the Americas’ industrial progress and achievement, had attracted visitors from around the world. The event was more than halfway through its six-month run when President McKinley, the most popular chief executive since Abraham Lincoln, arrived.

McKinley’s final public appearance in Buffalo was an afternoon reception in the Temple of Music, an ornate red-brick hall on the exposition grounds. Since being elected president in 1896, McKinley had been notorious for discounting his own personal safety at public appearances, and he had repeatedly resisted attempts by his personal secretary, George Cortelyou, to cancel this event. Cortelyou had argued that it wasn’t worth the risk to greet such a small number of people, but the 58-year-old president refused to change his mind. ‘Why should I?’ he asked. ‘Who would want to hurt me?’

Cortelyou, always nervous about public receptions, tightened security as best he could. The people who wished to greet the president at the Temple had to file down a narrow aisle under the scrutiny of a special guard provided for the occasion. Outside, mounted police and soldiers controlled the massive crowd seeking entrance.

Just months into his second presidential term, McKinley — who had easily won reelection in 1900 — had made the most significant speech of his presidency the day before, announcing a policy of reciprocal trade agreements with foreign nations to encourage improved markets for American goods. It marked the culmination of a decade-long evolution in thinking for the long-time isolationist and exemplified his statesmanship in recognition of changing times.

McKinley’s star first rose on the national scene some 10 years earlier as the Republican Party’s staunchest advocate of protectionism. He believed that high tariffs discouraged the importation of foreign goods, thereby helping keep prices high for American goods and producing profits for industries and high wages for workers. Using protectionism as his platform for election to the U.S. House of Representatives and the Ohio statehouse, where he served two terms as governor, McKinley established himself as his party’s standard-bearer. According to biographer Margaret Leech, McKinley ‘carried to Congress an emotional conviction that the solution for all the country’s economic ills was to make the already high tariff rates higher still.’ By 1900, however, he saw reciprocity as a means for commercial expansion and a way to promote world peace.

McKinley was a veteran of the Civil War and retained vivid memories of the bloody conflict. As president, he was reluctantly drawn into the Spanish-American War of 1898. At first he downplayed stories of Spanish atrocities against Cuban nationals. But the yellow journalism of competing newspaper publishers William Randolph Hearst and Joseph Pulitzer fired passions after the battleship Maine exploded and sank in Havana’s harbor. Big business, looking to expand markets, added to the inexorable forces pushing the president toward war.

Spain proved little challenge though, as American forces easily defeated the outnumbered and out-gunned army and navy of the Old World power. As the victor, the United States gained Puerto Rico, Wake, Guam, and the Philippines. The Pacific Islands were particularly significant as they established an American presence in a new hemisphere. Moreover, the United States annexed the Hawaiian Islands that summer. American business concerns became ecstatic over the prospects for expanded influence overseas. But not everyone supported the president. Hearst in particular continued to publicly criticize him. The condemnation reached a low point on April 10, 1901, when the publisher’s Journal printed an editorial that declared, ‘If bad institutions and bad men can be got rid of only by killing, then the killing must be done.’ Although Hearst had been responsible for many attacks on McKinley, he maintained that the editorial had been published without his knowledge. He ordered the presses stopped, but a number of newspapers were already on the streets.

On September 5 an estimated 50,000 people, including Leon Czolgosz, had listened to the president’s speech. ‘Isolation is no longer possible or desirable,’ McKinley said. ‘The period of exclusiveness is past. The expansion of our trade and commerce is the pressing problem. Commercial wars are unprofitable. A policy of good-will and friendly trade relations will prevent reprisals.’ The New York Times, remarking on the president’s about-face, wrote, ‘Unquestionably the President has learned much in the last few years.’

Unfortunately, America’s move toward imperialism had done little for the common workingman. Already frustrated by years of economic depression that began with the Panic of 1893, and by the lack of progress toward more humane working conditions, American workers wondered why some of the vast wealth of the industrial boom wasn’t trickling down to them. Millionaires like railroad king Cornelius Vanderbilt, oil baron John D. Rockefeller, steel magnate Andrew Carnegie, and banker J.P. Morgan had accumulated unprecedented private wealth and were known to spend more on an evening’s entertainment than a coal miner or tradesman could earn in a lifetime. Such ostentatious displays bred discontent. Rubbing salt in the wound, the industrialists routinely relied on the government to help squelch worker uprisings.

Employee unions had progressively become a more dominant force in American life during the last quarter of the nineteenth century as they sought to improve working conditions. Strikers had clashed violently with police and the military in Chicago’s Haymarket Riot in 1886 and again in the Pullman strike eight years later, leaving scores of people dead in the streets. In 1892, Pinkerton detectives in Homestead, Pennsylvania, suppressed a steel strike and protected scab laborers. The government had sided with management against workers in each instance.

A more dangerous element — anarchism — exacerbated the situation when it arrived from Europe. Anarchists brought a more radical philosophy to the scene, maintaining that any form of government exploited and oppressed the people. They believed that one way to combat government was to eliminate those in power. Since 1894, anarchists had assassinated four European leaders — President Sadi Carnot of France, Empress Elizabeth of Austria, King Humbert of Italy, and Spanish statesman Cnovas del Castillo. In the United States, an anarchist had attacked industrialist Henry Clay Frick, in part for his role in the failed Homestead strike.

For some individuals with little or no formal education, few skills, and no hope of improvement, anarchism offered a natural outlet for their frustration. Cleveland resident Leon Czolgosz fit the profile perfectly. Poor, reclusive, and often unemployed, he had been born in Detroit to Polish parents in 1873. He left school after five and a half years and worked at various jobs and later drifted to Chicago and became interested in the socialist movement. The interest continued in Cleveland, where he took a job in the city’s wire mills. Two weeks before he traveled to Buffalo, Czolgosz attended a lecture given by the nation’s most notorious anarchist leader, Emma Goldman. She spoke of the struggle between the classes and why the time had come for action against government.

Surrounded by his entourage inside the Temple of Music, McKinley enjoyed the opportunity to meet his admirers. Host John Milburn, the exposition’s president, stood on the president’s left, so he could introduce acquaintances to McKinley as they approached. Secret Service agent George Foster, the president’s chief bodyguard, usually held that position, but he found himself five feet away from the president and standing opposite him. To McKinley’s right stood Cortelyou, who looked into the face of each person as they came close to his boss. He intended to signal the guards to close the doors after 10 minutes to stop the parade of well-wishers and then rush the president on to his next appointment.

President McKinley greeted each person with a warm smile and a handshake, pausing briefly to exchange words with any children who had accompanied their parents. The line moved quickly. Many in attendance held cloths to dab the sweat from their foreheads on the warm, humid day. As the waiting people shuffled forward, Foster noticed one man in line who had his right hand wrapped in a handkerchief. Foster wondered if it covered an embarrassing injury.

McKinley saw the man’s apparent disability, and he reached to shake his left hand. Suddenly, Leon Czolgosz thrust his bandaged right hand into the president’s chest. Onlookers heard two sharp popping sounds, like small firecrackers, and a thin veil of gray smoke rose up in front of the president. McKinley looked confused and rose up on his toes, clutched his chest, and leaned forward. Members of his entourage moved to support the slumping president and help him to a nearby chair as the blood spread across his white vest. ‘Be careful how you tell my wife,’ McKinley said, his strength already waning.

Foster and others pounced on the assailant, knocking him roughly to the floor as he tried to aim his revolver for a third shot. McKinley managed a weak, ‘Don’t let them hurt him,’ when he saw Czolgosz being pummeled beneath a mass of angry guards. As the pandemonium continued, aides rushed the president to a hospital on the exposition grounds. One bullet had struck his sternum a glancing blow, causing only a superficial wound, but the other had penetrated his abdomen, a potentially fatal injury.

Dr. Roswell Park, the exposition’s medical director and a surgeon with an international reputation, was performing a cancer operation in nearby Niagara Falls. Rather than wait for his return, the doctors present believed it imperative to act immediately, and they decided to operate as soon as prominent Buffalo surgeon Dr. Matthew Mann arrived.

At 5:20 p.m., an hour and 13 minutes after the shooting, President McKinley went under the knife. As he slipped into an ether-induced sleep, he murmured the Lord’s Prayer. Operating conditions were far from ideal, and professional lapses occurred that in retrospect probably raised an eyebrow or two, but the grave emergency required snap judgment. At one time doctors had to reflect the waning sun’s rays onto the patient with a mirror because of inadequate lighting.

An anxious crowd awaited word of the president’s condition. At 7:00 p.m. the physicians released a statement detailing the extent of McKinley’s injuries and describing the surgery, during which they had searched for but could not find the second bullet. Summing up, they said the president’s ‘condition at the conclusion of the operation was gratifying. The result cannot be foretold. His condition at present justifies hope of recovery.’

While initial reports were optimistic, as they would be for the next six days, one presidential adviser felt an uneasy foreboding. Secretary of State John Hay had already experienced the assassinations of two presidents — the first as a personal secretary to Abraham Lincoln and the second as a personal friend and confidant of James Garfield. Called to Buffalo from Washington, Hay reportedly told his escort that the president would surely die. But the secretary of state’s fear was an exception. The optimism of other reports prompted cabinet officials to return to their duties elsewhere. Vice President Theodore Roosevelt, who had rushed to the president’s bedside when he received news of the shooting, left Buffalo ‘with a light heart’ and joined his family on vacation in the Adirondacks.

The president improved daily, and he felt strong enough on the morning of September 12 to receive his first food orally — toast and coffee. McKinley’s spirits were good, but by afternoon he began to experience discomfort, and his condition rapidly worsened. Within 36 hours Hay’s prediction came true. Gangrene, unseen, had been forming along the path of the bullet for nearly a week. Some 40 years before penicillin became generally available, McKinley had been doomed the moment Czolgosz fired his revolver. The president died in the early morning hours of September 14, surrounded by a small group of family and friends. That afternoon Theodore Roosevelt was sworn in as president of the United States.

As doctors had removed the president to John Milburn’s house after surgery, another spectacle was playing out across town at police headquarters, where the anarchist’s life was in as great a peril as McKinley’s had been. Police brandishing rifles and soldiers with bayonets transported the assailant through an angry mob of thousands who called for Czolgosz’s head. Now an estimated crowd of 30,000 stood ready to rush the station to drag the prisoner from his cell. ‘Kill him! Lynch him!’ they demanded. One observer commented that the ‘roar of the crowd was never to be forgotten by anyone who heard it.’ Buffalo Police Superintendent William Bull’s quick action probably saved the prisoner’s life. Bull and his men, some of them mounted, used nightsticks to beat back the surging crowd and eventually managed to cordon off the street and surround the police station three deep, a daunting presence that discouraged mob action.

District Attorney Thomas Penney interrogated the would-be assassin inside the station. Czolgosz readily confessed. A self-described anarchist and disciple of Emma Goldman, Czolgosz said he had acted alone. ‘I killed President McKinley because I done my duty,’ he explained without emotion. ‘I didn’t believe one man should have so much service and another man should have none.’

From his cell across the street from city hall, Czolgosz must have heard the caisson carrying McKinley’s remains roll slowly through the streets of Buffalo on September 16 on its way to the train station for its journey to Washington, D.C. There the president’s body was placed under the Capitol dome in the same chamber that once housed the remains of Lincoln and Garfield, before completing its trip for burial in McKinley’s hometown of Canton, Ohio.

Czolgosz was indicted and arraigned on September 16, and the trial commenced one week later in Buffalo’s city hall. The accused, resigned and unrepentant, pled guilty, but Judge Truman C. White, one of the most experienced of New York’s supreme court justices, instructed the court clerk to enter a plea of not guilty in accordance with New York state law. Loran L. Lewis and Robert C. Titus, the two retired justices of the state supreme court appointed to serve as defense counsel, didn’t hide their disgust at having been handed the assignment.

District Attorney Penney focused on the medical aspects of the president’s wound and death. During cross-examination, Dr. Herman Mynter, one of the attending physicians, discussed why the doctors did not find the second bullet. He explained that given McKinley’s weakened condition, further search risked killing him on the operating table. Doctors did not find the bullet during the autopsy, he noted, because the McKinley family did not want the body mutilated.

The prosecution then established beyond any doubt that the defendant had committed the crime. Czolgosz’s signed confession and interrogation immediately after the shooting confirmed his guilt. The only hope for a not-guilty verdict remained with the question of the defendant’s mental state, a matter of much newspaper speculation in the weeks preceding the trial. The prosecution and the defense had engaged six psychiatrists to examine Czolgosz, but the alienists, as they were then known, found no evidence of insanity. Defense counsel never even raised the issue until closing arguments, and then only weakly. In fact, defense counsel called no witnesses on Czolgosz’s behalf. In fairness, though, the defendant refused to discuss the matter with either attorney, leaving them little on which to base a defense.

The state rested its case after just one and a half days, and the judge issued his instructions to the jury. In 30 minutes they returned with the expected verdict — guilty in the first degree. The trial had been a model of expediency, but it hardly represented an example of a strong defense. By today’s standards it would likely result in a mistrial on appeal. But in 1901, given the crime’s dastardly nature and a public calling for blood, defense counsel did not file an appeal.

The following month, the state of New York carried out Czolgosz’s death sentence at the penitentiary in Auburn. The warden received more than 1,000 requests for invitations to the execution, but he allowed only 26 witnesses in accordance with state law. Prison officials also rejected two morbid proposals — one from a museum curator to buy the corpse for $5,000 and another from a kinescope operator for $2,000 to film the condemned man’s walk to the death chamber. On October 29 the executioner threw a switch and sent 1,700 volts of electricity through Czolgosz’s body. Officials were afraid that removal of Czolgosz’s corpse might cause a spectacle, so they secured the family’s permission to inter it in the prison cemetery. Prison guards doused the body with sulfuric acid to render it unrecognizable. At Czolgosz’s request, the prison chaplain did not conduct a religious ceremony.

In spite of death threats made towards McKinley during his presidency, he had been protected by the most casual and primitive security. The president had often walked unattended in Canton and strolled alone on the White House grounds without George Foster in attendance. After his death — the third presidential assassination in 36 years — Congress stepped up security for United States presidents by directing the Secret Service to add the protection of the president to its duties. Two years later, Congress enacted legislation that made presidential protection a permanent Secret Service responsibility.

This article was written by Wyatt Kingseed and originally appeared in the October 2001 issue of American History magazine. For more great articles, subscribe to American History magazine today!

27 Responses to President William McKinley: Assassinated by an Anarchist

  1. butch says:

    funny how in each assasination the killers are always self motivated. There is never a real reason for their slaying of the president. And the media, intellegents, places a mad dog sticker on the killers back before their thrown into oblivion. I think the real people behind each and every killing are an invisible intity known only by an elite society of industrial powers. Policies and war abroad has always been about business resources and capital gain. Wake up America!

    • brittany says:

      are you a conspricy theorist? i think you are……. otherwise you have some MAYJOR issues!……. …………….just sayin

      • Carrie says:

        Butch is right, did you know that Randolph Hearst was a member of the Bohemian Club? He was kicked out after the assassination of McKinley, look it up on Wikipedia. So then Hearst & 14 of his reporters, editor’s, etc. left & started the Family Club in 1901. How Hearst gets kicked out of the Bohemian Club, because of the McKinley scandal, when I think Hearst owns the Bohemian property, is beyond me. Maybe Brittany can answer this one, or someone else please. I’ve done a lot of research myself, but do not know the owner of the Bohemian Club in 1901, one source has told me, Hearst owned it. What is the Bohemian Club? Well I don’t know anyone that explains it better than Alex Jones on Youtube.
        My New Year’s Resolution is that we all need to wake up!

      • Matt says:

        You spelled conspiracy and major wrong…………………..just saying.

      • freedom over slavery says:

        the conspiracy is the stupification of the public. they know more about sports and fashion than the truth…case in point

  2. brittany howard says:

    who published this website?

    • Carrie says:

      Source: Phoenix Rising: The Rise & Fall of The American Revolution
      Source: Brotherhood of the Bomb: The Tangled Lives & Loyalty of Robert
      Many sources & publications have been written in regard to the Hearst, Roosevelt incident. However, because the Bohemian Grove is so secret, it is difficult to gain information. The Bohemian Grove is as secret as the Bilderberg Group & Skulls & Bones.
      Research Randolph Hearsts, Family Club also.
      The best source of information available is from Alex Jones, “”
      He snuck into the Bohemian Grove in 2000 & film some of the rituals. He did not however break any laws because of the Logan Act. The world leader’s do not want you to know what goes on there, or they would not keep it a secret. I know what they are working on, it’s a one world government, “New World Order”.

      • Cody says:

        Carrie the “New World Order” are the Free Masons! You need to learn history! This is what is wrong with all the cobspiracy theorists tey get things wrong all the time!

  3. Cody says:

    Ok Carrie first of all if you are using Wikipedia as a “source” then you know nothing about relative sources. Everyone knows that Wikipedia has many lies. @ Butch, ofcourse they are self motivated! Assasins and serial killers have the same mentality. On top of eing self motivated they are extremely narsasitic which shows that they only care about their “mission”. If you are trying to become a conspiracy theorist start off with the Kennedy Assination, i believe it will be much easier for you to understand. Also, Brittany i agree with you 100 percent.

    • Carrie says:

      You will need to do you’re own research.
      Their is no conspiracy behind the Bohemian Grove, Bilderberg Group, & Skulls & Bones, because they exist, except they are done in secret, why?
      They don’t want you to know what they are doing? I think it’s working.

    • freedom over slavery says:

      cody and brittany are not as educated as they think they are. Butch is definatly on the right path…question what the media tells you to believe , this is not a new tactic or plan, it is ages old and it always works on the masses. there is a new world order, they are the old world order and your lives and freedoms are in great peril. the information is out there…

  4. […] McKinley was assassinated in the summer. […]

  5. […] worth remembering that U.S. history is filled with terrorist attacks from anarchists, Puerto Rican nationalists, left-wing militants like the Weather Underground, white supremacists […]

  6. […] worth remembering that U.S. history is filled with terrorist attacks from anarchists, Puerto Rican nationalists, left-wing militants like the Weather Underground, white supremacists […]

  7. […] worth remembering that U.S. history is filled with terrorist attacks from anarchists, Puerto Rican nationalists, left-wing militants like the Weather Underground, white supremacists […]

  8. […] Buffalo en el año 1901 y en cuyos pabellones se presentó por primera vez la máquina de rayos X, máquina cuyo empleo fue desdeñado por los médicos que no se fiaban de sus efectos secundarios, dando como resultado que la segunda bala se quedo dentro del cuerpo del Presidente haciendo de […]

  9. Jonny Indiana says:

    Read an article “Phelps “wrote about why the “J.F.K. assassination was the achelies heel” of this very old system, its many pages, get ready to digest a 500 year report, it’ll restructure your world outlook if your open, it did me, and I thought I knew a lot, wrong! Google what’s in parentheses, it’ll be good for you. And do please see and and realize that truth doesn’t need you or me to be so. Truth keeps right on being what it is whether we comply with it or not, it needs no help to be what it is, period. This for many is quite terrifying in that our human abilities without God are minscuel, tiny, and pitiful. Those with His wonderful ways and nature are killed, murdered, lambasted, castrated, mutilated, rapped, beaten, eaten, burned, and of course I’m sorry I almost forgot, ASSASSINATION as well. When any people, black, white, Philipino, American Indian, Australian, Black African, white African, any people put on the ways of God throughout history they have always gone through extreme persecusions ect. Those that have written history have power and money, yet there is a history inside of written history but its reserved for those that desire truth not a sweet history message alone. Yes if one wants to see, then they must ask permission from The One Who gives all sight freely without any partiality, with no favoratism what so ever. He is not a religion, a movement, a political party, a philosophy, rather He’s our freedom, and exquisidely so, needing no help from us to be. This Oct 2012 will be 25 years for me to be inside His family, He started me off in a mission in Eureka California, had lived on the streets, been in jail, justly so, done many foolish things as a misguided youth. Now having been all over the world, lived in Africa, and travelled extensively, am so greatful for His providential wisdom and care, its priceless. My Maker is my Maker, my mother is my mother, my father was my father. But my family is all over this world, and I’ve met thousands of them of every tribe, nation, tounge and people, it is so wonderful and yet so simple as well. Bless all those that seek Love and truth, they will find it. To all who read, please read with only a hope and trust that there is still Love, goodness, rightness, kindness, truthfulness, purity, gladness, Spiritual direction, clear instruction for those that believe, protection for the youth though so many are abused, and beauty and peace for those that are weak and need strength, I’m just one little man with all his inabilities, yet do trust my Maker for all., God bless all.

  10. Lizzie says:

    Butch, Carrie, Brittany, and Cody:
    You all need to proofread your arguments because your grammar usage is severely lacking.
    A few simple rules:
    -There is no ‘a’ in ‘definitely’. If you spell ‘definitely’ with an ‘a,’ you are ‘definately’ an a-hole.
    -You’re= you+are. Your= possessive

    Lastly, no one actually listens to your theories; you’re commenting on the bottom of an article about President McKinley. Go get a life. If you so insist on these conspiracy theories, involve them in your life. Don’t have meaningless arguments on the internet.

    • Edmund says:

      Thanks Lizzie,
      I started to wonder if there is hidden meaning behind the severely mangled words and noticed that shallow literacy breeds deep conspiracy.

  11. […] de breedste zin des woords, dus van de rijke historie van het anarchisme in Amerika, waarin er nog presidenten werden neergeschoten, tot heden, waarin nieuwe vormen van anti-authoritair denken ontpoppen, zoals het libertarisme. Ook […]

  12. […] his confidence and suggested McKinley it wasn’t value a risk to hail a tiny series of people. “Who would wish to harm me?” McKinley asked, rather […]

  13. […] his confidence and suggested McKinley it wasn’t value a risk to hail a tiny series of people. “Who would wish to harm me?” McKinley asked, rather […]

  14. […] one. If an assassination attempt were made, we figured, it would most likely be by another of the deranged anarchists or disgruntled office-seekers or Fair Play for Cuba activists or Manson family members or […]

  15. […] security and advised McKinley it wasn’t worth the risk to greet a small number of people. “Who would want to hurt me?” McKinley asked, rather […]

  16. Art Vandelay says:

    nice article about the hero, Leon Czolgosz. kudos

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

, , , ,