Comments on: Interview with George Custer Expert James Donovan http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm From the World's Largest History Magazine Publisher Sat, 21 Nov 2009 23:31:52 -0500 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.4 hourly 1 By: NorPlains http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-148254 NorPlains Wed, 18 Nov 2009 07:34:19 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-148254 I have not read Mr Donovan's book so I don't know what conclusions he arrives at regarding how the battle onfolded. But of the Custer books and narratives I have read the one I found the most compelling (as far as how the battle itself unfolded) was Sole Survivor by Douglas W. Ellison. I'm not talking about the sole survivor (Frank Finkel) that he presents in this book, but rather the troop movements (Custer's)and most probable strategies employed. I think archaeological evidence that was later found in the scientific investigation after the grass fire on the battlefield bears his theory out. I have not read Mr Donovan’s book so I don’t know what conclusions he arrives at regarding how the battle onfolded. But of the Custer books and narratives I have read the one I found the most compelling (as far as how the battle itself unfolded) was Sole Survivor by Douglas W. Ellison. I’m not talking about the sole survivor (Frank Finkel) that he presents in this book, but rather the troop movements (Custer’s)and most probable strategies employed. I think archaeological evidence that was later found in the scientific investigation after the grass fire on the battlefield bears his theory out.

]]> By: Richard Jesse http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-86187 Richard Jesse Thu, 09 Jul 2009 04:26:08 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-86187 I would like to know what clothing, equipment the 7th Cavalry wore at Little Big Horn. We are trying to do an authentic copy of the troopers gear. Thanks, Richard I would like to know what clothing, equipment the 7th Cavalry wore at Little Big Horn. We are trying to do an authentic copy of the troopers gear. Thanks, Richard

]]> By: LaMar Stellfox http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-73684 LaMar Stellfox Mon, 08 Jun 2009 04:28:40 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-73684 I have just finished Mr. Donovan's superb book and want to tell him what a great work of history he produced. I too, like many others have read many of the more recommended books on the subject of the Battle of the Little Bighorn, and Mr. Donovan's book is by far the most readable, complete, and entertaining. Truly a modern classic of history. Well done sir! Thanks for confirming my conclusions as to Custer's greatest mistakes. I agree that his mistakes were violating the principle of mass and lack of any reconnaissance of the actual objective area. His narrative just feels so complete as to allow the reader to truly reach finality on the subject. I have just finished Mr. Donovan’s superb book and want to tell him what a great work of history he produced. I too, like many others have read many of the more recommended books on the subject of the Battle of the Little Bighorn, and Mr. Donovan’s book is by far the most readable, complete, and entertaining. Truly a modern classic of history. Well done sir! Thanks for confirming my conclusions as to Custer’s greatest mistakes. I agree that his mistakes were violating the principle of mass and lack of any reconnaissance of the actual objective area. His narrative just feels so complete as to allow the reader to truly reach finality on the subject.

]]> By: Myles Keough http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-65642 Myles Keough Mon, 25 May 2009 17:27:49 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-65642 I have yet to read the book, however, many accounts of the resulting battle tend to not include contributing factors.Custer's hatred of Ulysses S. Grant and his preoccupation with becoming the next President of the USA resulted in his haste, leaving gattling guns behind as not to slow the 7th Cavary down so he could travel to Washington to declare his candidacy. Disentary, among the troops. Being undergunned, single-shot breechloaders vs. the indians Winchesters. The troops carrying 4-months backpay having been paid just before the campaign. I have yet to read the book, however, many accounts of the resulting battle tend to not include contributing factors.Custer’s hatred of Ulysses S. Grant and his preoccupation with becoming the next President of the USA resulted in his haste, leaving gattling guns behind as not to slow the 7th Cavary down so he could travel to Washington to declare his candidacy. Disentary, among the troops. Being undergunned, single-shot breechloaders vs. the indians Winchesters. The troops carrying 4-months backpay having been paid just before the campaign.

]]> By: Peter Thompson http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-65296 Peter Thompson Mon, 25 May 2009 02:15:10 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-65296 Like the life of Sinatra, the full scope of Custer and his accension into the american consciousness will probably prove too big for Hollywood, and too politically incorrect to even attempt to objectify in the wake of the red mans plight in our nation. I would pay to see the definitive portrayal of Custer in an Olver Stone film however, if for no other reason than to just piss off the status quo. I think that alone would have pleased Custer. Like the life of Sinatra, the full scope of Custer and his accension into the american consciousness will probably prove too big for Hollywood, and too politically incorrect to even attempt to objectify in the wake of the red mans plight in our nation. I would pay to see the definitive portrayal of Custer in an Olver Stone film however, if for no other reason than to just piss off the status quo. I think that alone would have pleased Custer.

]]> By: Jon Heitland http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-60455 Jon Heitland Tue, 12 May 2009 20:03:42 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-60455 I am a 30 year Custer "buff" and have read dozens of books on the battle, been to the battlefield every year, re-enacted the battle, etc., and I truly believe "A Terrible Glory" is the best book on the subject in many years, maybe the best of all with the possible exception of William Graham's "The Custer Myth". He has done an excellent job of synthesizing all the available information, the new with the old, and in a very readable fashion. I think it will be the new "gold standard" among Custer scholars. I am a 30 year Custer “buff” and have read dozens of books on the battle, been to the battlefield every year, re-enacted the battle, etc., and I truly believe “A Terrible Glory” is the best book on the subject in many years, maybe the best of all with the possible exception of William Graham’s “The Custer Myth”. He has done an excellent job of synthesizing all the available information, the new with the old, and in a very readable fashion. I think it will be the new “gold standard” among Custer scholars.

]]> By: Dale Decker http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-56227 Dale Decker Tue, 28 Apr 2009 04:12:38 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-56227 Nice article. Haven't read the book yet, but I agree with one statement he made that kind of makes me want to read it. All too often historians have a specific point they wish to make, and even if unintentionally, tend to search for items that support that particular point, sometimes to the exclusion of other facts that may muddy the waters a bit. This is why I don't think I would read a book by Mr. Borroel. His comment above tends to make one think that he has already reached such a conclusion, and his book would probably support it. I much prefer to get all the facts from all sides, then determine for myself these things. So I will probably get Mr. Donavan's book. Nice article. Haven’t read the book yet, but I agree with one statement he made that kind of makes me want to read it. All too often historians have a specific point they wish to make, and even if unintentionally, tend to search for items that support that particular point, sometimes to the exclusion of other facts that may muddy the waters a bit.

This is why I don’t think I would read a book by Mr. Borroel. His comment above tends to make one think that he has already reached such a conclusion, and his book would probably support it. I much prefer to get all the facts from all sides, then determine for myself these things. So I will probably get Mr. Donavan’s book.

]]> By: Bill Stalzer http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-54609 Bill Stalzer Wed, 22 Apr 2009 15:56:32 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-54609 I'm a big fan of the West. It seems that Mr. Donovan has done is homework and you must respect that. I agree with Mr. Borroel about the Alamo and Thermopylae. I’m a big fan of the West. It seems that Mr. Donovan has done is
homework and you must respect that. I agree with Mr. Borroel about the Alamo and Thermopylae.

]]> By: tjaldie23@peoplepc.com http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-50574 tjaldie23@peoplepc.com Thu, 09 Apr 2009 04:18:10 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-50574 Arrogance in abundance. Humility non-existent. Arrogance in abundance. Humility non-existent.

]]> By: Roger Borroel http://www.historynet.com/interview-with-george-custer-expert-james-donovan.htm/comment-page-1#comment-50454 Roger Borroel Wed, 08 Apr 2009 20:32:38 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13680879#comment-50454 As for the new Alamo book, there are PLENTY of realiable, military, Mexican side accounts, all written down shortly after the battle, in pen. However, one has to do their research, however, they(the mss) are practically under our noses! These accounts are backed up by Mexican army charts, and official dispatches, papers, and Mexican field reports. No tepee here. Also, I hope that Mr. Donovan does not compare the Alamo and Thermopylae as if they are the same in spirit and purpose. Many people wrongfully do this erroneous comparison, however, they are as different as night and day. For instance, the ancient Greeks were really defending their home ground from an invader, however, the so-called, Anglo-Texans were in the process of STEALING land! See the difference, folks? I know you do. As for the new Alamo book, there are PLENTY of realiable, military, Mexican side accounts, all written down shortly after the battle, in pen. However, one has to do their research, however, they(the mss) are practically under our noses! These accounts are backed up by Mexican army charts, and official dispatches, papers, and Mexican field reports. No tepee here. Also, I hope that Mr. Donovan does not compare the Alamo and Thermopylae as if they are the same in spirit and purpose. Many people wrongfully do this erroneous comparison, however, they are as different as night and day. For instance, the ancient Greeks were really defending their home ground from an invader, however, the so-called, Anglo-Texans were in the process of STEALING land! See the difference, folks? I know you do.

]]>