Following the trail of Wilcox money, the Pinkertons quickly tracked Lonnie and Bob to Cripple Creek, Colo. Before the detectives could close in, however, Lonnie left town and headed home to the Lee farm in Dodson, Mo. Bob, meanwhile, found a job dealing cards at the Antlers Gambling House, where on February 28 the Pinkertons arrested him for the Wilcox train robbery. On May 5, Lee gave a deposition to U.S. Marshal Frank A. Hadsell and Pinkerton Superintendent John C. Fraser. According to his statement, Lee had a torn Wilcox bill in his possession only because Lonnie Logan had been paid a debt by the Sundance Kid, and Lonnie in turn had given the bill to Lee. Bob's trial began on May 24 in the federal court in Cheyenne, Wyo., and on May 28 he was found guilty and sentenced to 10 years in the Wyoming State Penitentiary, then located at Rawlins.

Subscribe Today

• Did you enjoy our article?
• Read more in Wild West magazine
• Subscribe online and save nearly 40%!!!
 

On February 28, the same day Bob Lee was captured, Pinkerton agents went to the Lee farm looking for Lonnie. Accompanied by three Kansas City detectives, the Pinkertons tried to sneak up on the farmhouse. However, the house, according to the Pinkertons, was 'at the apex of a steep grade. No stealthy approach to it was possible, as the ground in front of it was open terrain…a strip of woods several hundred feet away.' Having spotted the agents outside, Lonnie tried to sneak out the back door and escape into the woods at the rear of the property. The Pinkertons saw him running and shot to kill. Lonnie landed in a snowbank and died instantly. William A. Pinkerton later praised his agents' work, saying that Superintendent Kimble of the Spokane office 'had more to do with the killing of Logan than all of the other people who were present.' When Harvey heard that his brother had been killed and his cousin was in jail, his anger reached its peak; he was determined to kill any and all law officers he could.

Late in March 1900, a rural postal clerk saw Harvey Logan and Will Carver near St. Johns, Arizona Territory, and reported the suspicious pair to Sheriff Edward Beeler. A posse took off after the outlaws and tracked them for days before most of them gave up. Two Mormon boys from the posse, Andrew A. Gibbons and Frank LeSeuer, stuck with the trail. Logan spotted the two young possemen, and they soon rode right into his ambush. Harvey fired just two shots and killed them both. It was March 28, just one month after Lonnie's death.

Still on the run, Logan and Carver headed south toward the WS Ranch in Alma, New Mexico Territory, where the Wild Bunch outlaws occasionally hid. Along the way, they stopped near the San Simon River to butcher a cow, and a passing lawman discovered their handiwork. Sheriff George Scarborough and cattleman Walter Birchfield followed the trail of the suspected cattle rustlers, but rode into an ambush on April 5. Birchfield was only wounded, but Scarborough soon died in Deming, New Mexico Territory. Logan's search for revenge had now claimed another victim. Two weeks later, on April 17, while out tracking down cattle rustlers, Sheriff Jesse M. Tyler of Grand County, Utah, shot down Flatnose George Currie. Flatnose had been one of the most important influences in Harvey Logan's life other than his own brothers, and Harvey again set out to even the score. Bitter, enraged and bent on vengeance, Logan headed north in search of the sheriff. On May 26, he found Tyler and deputized cattleman Sam Jenkins looking for a local cattle rustler on Hill Creek, about 40 miles north of Thompson Springs, Utah. Logan shot and killed them both. The Pinkerton criminal history dossier on Harvey states, 'Logan committed this murder for revenge because Tyler and Jenkins were of the posse that had killed George Curry [sic], April 17th preceding.'

Five murders in two months was vengeance aplenty, but whether Logan really was responsible for them can be debated. The newspapers of the day all name Tom Capehart as one of a gang of outlaws in each of the five cases, and the references further claim that the name 'Tom Capehart' was an alias being used by Harvey Logan. Capehart was actually a Texas cowboy who happened to work with many of Harvey's outlaw acquaintances. So while the Pinkertons were quick to add LeSeuer, Gibbons, Scarborough, Tyler and Jenkins to the list of men murdered by Logan, he may have been innocent of those charges. The murderer may actually have been Tom Capehart. There is little question, however, that Logan would have been pleased to hear about the deaths of these lawmen.

Help HistoryNet by bookmarking to