Comments on: Film Spurs Russia to Squelch Criticism of Soviet War Tactics http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics From the World's Largest History Magazine Publisher Wed, 15 Feb 2012 06:00:30 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3 By: lenin chigbundu http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-788312 lenin chigbundu Sun, 05 Feb 2012 19:00:38 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-788312 i watched the documentary on youtube about the soviet storm...how come you omitted the operational details about the finnish-karelia front in 1944...you ruskies didnt really go there or were the finns fighting squirrels in the woods? you chose to occupy the whole of balkan and eastern europe but left finland out of it...because they won their defensive battles against and wore you out so you elected to go an armistice...you knew they had better partisans prepared to fight you all the way to the arctic circle. when you narrate history tell us the whole truth...as you can see we are not exactly stupid...oh and do not forget stalin wanted to return to finland in 1940 but he was waiting for Germany to open operation seelion. as academic technicians we hate lies i watched the documentary on youtube about the soviet storm…how come you omitted the operational details about the finnish-karelia front in 1944…you ruskies didnt really go there or were the finns fighting squirrels in the woods?
you chose to occupy the whole of balkan and eastern europe but left finland out of it…because they won their defensive battles against and wore you out so you elected to go an armistice…you knew they had better partisans prepared to fight you all the way to the arctic circle. when you narrate history tell us the whole truth…as you can see we are not exactly stupid…oh and do not forget stalin wanted to return to finland in 1940 but he was waiting for Germany to open operation seelion.
as academic technicians we hate lies

]]> By: lenin chigbundu http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-788311 lenin chigbundu Sun, 05 Feb 2012 18:42:43 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-788311 with stalins oil and minerals hitler prosecuted the war in the west...from the coast of france he should have turned back to head for the east while leaving the uk to recover. stalin the blackmailer had a good resource of oil for sale..hitler did not want to buy them any more...he just wanted to have it all for himself. taht is why he planned operation blue for oil and i understand his sentiments here. with stalins oil and minerals hitler prosecuted the war in the west…from the coast of france he should have turned back to head for the east while leaving the uk to recover. stalin the blackmailer had a good resource of oil for sale..hitler did not want to buy them any more…he just wanted to have it all for himself. taht is why he planned operation blue for oil and i understand his sentiments here.

]]> By: lenin chigbundu http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-788310 lenin chigbundu Sun, 05 Feb 2012 18:37:54 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-788310 when shamir the chechen leader suggested this to putin...what was your own answer when shamir the chechen leader suggested this to putin…what was your own answer

]]> By: lenin chigbundu http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-788309 lenin chigbundu Sun, 05 Feb 2012 18:21:54 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-788309 these are the facts...most of the divisons that fought on the eastern front were rested in the west or south to refit, rest and retrain wtih new equipment. stalin knew this and presurised churchill to open a second front. the americans knew as much and made it clear that they would only support the opening of a second front. chruchill just as the coward that he is wanted the second front to enguf the whole of the balkan peninsula with the SOE doing most of the dirty work and the balkan peoples suffering as result while hitler placed thirty divisions in france with most of them understrength, he maintained almost two hundred divisions on the eastern front continually. when the battle of the bulge pricked churchill he picked up the phone with lips quivering in the cold to petition Uncle jOE to open the floodgates of the eastern front for him. these are the facts…most of the divisons that fought on the eastern front were rested in the west or south to refit, rest and retrain wtih new equipment. stalin knew this and presurised churchill to open a second front. the americans knew as much and made it clear that they would only support the opening of a second front. chruchill just as the coward that he is wanted the second front to enguf the whole of the balkan peninsula with the SOE doing most of the dirty work and the balkan peoples suffering as result
while hitler placed thirty divisions in france with most of them understrength, he maintained almost two hundred divisions on the eastern front continually.
when the battle of the bulge pricked churchill he picked up the phone with lips quivering in the cold to petition Uncle jOE to open the floodgates of the eastern front for him.

]]> By: lenin chigbundu http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-788308 lenin chigbundu Sun, 05 Feb 2012 18:14:12 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-788308 i support your sentiments...the education system supported bilingualism to foster literacy...in terms of technical tuition, they were not too bad either...just check out the secret russian aircraft of ww2 and eat your bile dry. if Tuchachesky had been allowed to complete the modernization of the armoured forces for deep ...... operations we would have had the kv 1 tank mounting a much longer 76.2 and another mounting the definitive 107mm...that was what made hitler decide to last out at stalin. he knew that stalin had the resources to bring off this development while his industrialist were just taking their time. this is something i would like all students of world war two history to gesticulate on systematically i support your sentiments…the education system supported bilingualism to foster literacy…in terms of technical tuition, they were not too bad either…just check out the secret russian aircraft of ww2 and eat your bile dry. if Tuchachesky had been allowed to complete the modernization of the armoured forces for deep …… operations we would have had the kv 1 tank mounting a much longer 76.2 and another mounting the definitive 107mm…that was what made hitler decide to last out at stalin. he knew that stalin had the resources to bring off this development while his industrialist were just taking their time. this is something i would like all students of world war two history to gesticulate on systematically

]]> By: lenin chigbundu http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-788307 lenin chigbundu Sun, 05 Feb 2012 18:09:15 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-788307 contact on facebook under my name you have forgotten that poland shared territory at the expense of Rumania before the German attack in September..how come no one is talking about that or do we all have short memories...let us not forget that the poles wanted to negotiate with hitler about the danzig corridor and the british sent diplomatic soundings to hitler that they would be amenable to negotiations. what spoiled the whole thing was when ribbentrop read up a draft of sixteen points for the british ambassodor but refused to make a copy available to the poles because they had not turned up for the meeting. perhaps i will like to add that the polish ambassodor turned up to state that the poles were favourbly disposed to negotiations but he did not have the authority to sign on behalf of his country. that was when hitler decided to send his armies into poland...this time he had to explain to his general staff that he wanted living space in the east and poland would be the conduit to that promised land. you do not need to be sorry for poland...they did grab some territorial morsels fed to them by the Germans...when the time came hitler to have the danzig corridor, the poles decided to become difficult. contact on facebook under my name
you have forgotten that poland shared territory at the expense of Rumania before the German attack in September..how come no one is talking about that or do we all have short memories…let us not forget that the poles wanted to negotiate with hitler about the danzig corridor and the british sent diplomatic soundings to hitler that they would be amenable to negotiations. what spoiled the whole thing was when ribbentrop read up a draft of sixteen points for the british ambassodor but refused to make a copy available to the poles because they had not turned up for the meeting.

perhaps i will like to add that the polish ambassodor turned up to state that the poles were favourbly disposed to negotiations but he did not have the authority to sign on behalf of his country. that was when hitler decided to send his armies into poland…this time he had to explain to his general staff that he wanted living space in the east and poland would be the conduit to that promised land.
you do not need to be sorry for poland…they did grab some territorial morsels fed to them by the Germans…when the time came hitler to have the danzig corridor, the poles decided to become difficult.

]]> By: L http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-780573 L Sat, 05 Nov 2011 23:55:06 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-780573 Why is it so offensive to suggest that Soviet loses were so heavy when the war started? Hitler broke the non-agression pact and took the Soviet Union by surprise. There's nothing dishonorable about being cheated. Why is it so offensive to suggest that Soviet loses were so heavy when the war started? Hitler broke the non-agression pact and took the Soviet Union by surprise. There's nothing dishonorable about being cheated.

]]> By: R. Teerink http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-780404 R. Teerink Wed, 02 Nov 2011 19:44:40 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-780404 The people of the Sovjet Union paid a high price to defeat Nazism, Without that sacrifice the outcome of WWII would have been different ... The history of Russia and (USSR) can be read in the eyes of these people..uptill today... The people of the Sovjet Union paid a high price to defeat Nazism, Without that sacrifice the outcome of WWII would have been different … The history of Russia and (USSR) can be read in the eyes of these people..uptill today…

]]> By: Boris Hayete http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-727256 Boris Hayete Thu, 01 Sep 2011 16:57:25 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-727256 The cost of 25 million lives is definitely a problem. The main reason the victory cost us 25 million lives is that the price of victory didn't matter to the government. Had Stalin and his clique spent more time 'crying over a few thousand', the war would have gone very differently, and might even have been avoided (we'll never know). The cost of 25 million lives is definitely a problem. The main reason the victory cost us 25 million lives is that the price of victory didn't matter to the government. Had Stalin and his clique spent more time 'crying over a few thousand', the war would have gone very differently, and might even have been avoided (we'll never know).

]]> By: jim http://www.historynet.com/film-spurs-russia-to-squelch-criticism-of-soviet-war-tactics.htm#comment-708797 jim Wed, 24 Aug 2011 08:41:44 +0000 http://www.historynet.com/?p=13681005#comment-708797 Hitler had eyes on the USSR; see Mein Kampf. Then he went into Poland first; why did he not go West? He needed to move towards his arch--enemy Stalin. And if the West had left him alone - what then? From Hitler's own mouth come words that spelt doom - 11 August 1939 and Hitler speaks privately with Carl Burckhardt (Commissioner in Danzig) "Everything I undertake is directed against the Russians. If the West is too stupid and blind to grasp this, then I shall be compelled to come to an agreement with the Russians, beat the West and then after their defeat turn turn against the Soviet Union with all my forces. I need the Ukraine so that they can't starve us out, as happened in the last war" Do we need any better explanation of the reason for the War? This is QED. Hitler had eyes on the USSR; see Mein Kampf. Then he went into Poland first; why did he not go West? He needed to move towards his arch–enemy Stalin. And if the West had left him alone – what then? From Hitler's own mouth come words that spelt doom – 11 August 1939 and Hitler speaks privately with Carl Burckhardt (Commissioner in Danzig) "Everything I undertake is directed against the Russians. If the West is too stupid and blind to grasp this, then I shall be compelled to come to an agreement with the Russians, beat the West and then after their defeat turn turn against the Soviet Union with all my forces. I need the Ukraine so that they can't starve us out, as happened in the last war" Do we need any better explanation of the reason for the War? This is QED.

]]>